SECRET MENU > FICTION
He says he’ll ruin me. That’s his word: ruin. This guy, this customer with a face consisting mostly of beard matter, he stands by the door on his way out, angling a large pizza box against his hip. He’s yelling that he’s going to tell all his friends not to eat here. Then he actually jabs a pudgy finger skyward and howls, “I’ll ruin you!” And stomps off and slams the door. In the uprush of silence, everyone in the dining room, including a little girl coloring on a placemat, turns to see what I’ll do.
Why’s he going to ruin me? Because I charged him too much for his complicated pizza: a half Veggie Supreme with extra cheese, one-quarter green pesto, and one-quarter bianca with black olives, broccoli, and artichokes. When I told him the price, things escalated before I knew they could. The total, I was about to explain, included materials and labor. The application of the sauce, toppings, and cheese (quarantined into their fractional domains) required exceptional precision. Before I could come up with a normal way of saying that, though, he started in. He ran a business himself, he said, and this was no way to treat customers, and so on.
How will scaring away customers, Scooby-Doo style, ruin me? It won’t. But he thinks I’m the owner. The Deke of Deke’s Pizza. Granted, I’m a paunchy, slouched twenty-six-year-old bald man working among high school students. But I’m not Deke. In fact, there is no Deke. Deke was invented years ago by the real owner because he wanted, in his words, something manlier than Todd’s Pizza.
In that post-slam silence, I don’t give the dining room a second act. I just withdraw. I scuff out back to brood over the stainless steel sink filled with gray water and chopped veggie floaters.
It’d be a good image for a story. Dejected and haunted, our protagonist slouches over the cold, dingy sinkwater and imagines an ocean someplace far from his unremarkable life. The Sargasso Sea maybe. He reaches into the depths, pulls the stopper, and swishes his fist to start a vortex. Everything spirals down. Super symbolic!
I can’t remember the last thing I wrote, though. Whatever it was, it was a while ago—probably at college before I dropped out to pursue a career in pizza. And it wasn’t just the pizza; I had a lot on my plate. There was the freelance vodka consumption and recreational insomnia. And of course there was driving Maggie away via sustained emotional distance. That, just by itself, took a lot of energy.
Now, having been threatened with ruination, I do what fictional me would do. I spin the Sargasso Sea into a sucking maelstrom and imagine how things could’ve been different. I run the scenarios:
The rest of my Deke’s Pizza shift drains away, and I head home. I have a screwdriver and cigarette for supper and fall asleep on the couch. But a little after midnight, I snap awake with the first line of a short story in my head: “He says he’ll ruin me.”
I get my laptop. I write it all in one go. Like Kafka. I use a literary title that alludes to a line from Eliot. Around dawn, I have it. I have something, I mean. Whatever it is, though, it’s an embarrassment—thin, rambling, self-indulgent, lacking any kind of discernible point. Granted, it’s Raymond Carvery, but it’s more like Raymond Carver recovering from a head wound. Like “What We Talk About When We Talk About Whatever We Were Just Talking About.”
Still, I cut myself some slack. It is, after all, a draft. The first one in a long time. And it does have one redeeming scene. In the coda, there’s a quiet moment in which the protagonist almost understands something. Not an epiphany in the Joycean sense, but something new. The man, the one who isn’t me, he’s sitting in the living room as a shaft of sunlight slants in through the front window. The woman, the one who isn’t Maggie, has moved out.
We see flecks of dust swimming through the sunbeam, and the man remembers something from college about sunlight. The photons, born in the heart of the sun, have spent perhaps tens of thousands of years pushing their way through the sun’s churning plasma to finally reach the photosphere and then streak across ninety-three million miles in only eight minutes to his living room. After all that time and all that distance, the photons meet with particles of dust swirling in unpredictable patterns in this column of unspeakably ancient light.
Then, in the story, the phone rings.
Because the story’s set at a time before answering machines and caller ID, the man doesn’t know who’s calling. It could be her. He just doesn’t know. He could find out, of course, if he picked up. But he waits. He lets it ring. As long as the ringing continues, the caller can be considered both her and not her. If he doesn’t answer, that is. If he just holds on, it’s both. The man and the woman can be, without contradiction, both together and not together.
So he closes his eyes, listens to it ring, and does not think of moving.
*“Visions and Revisions” was inspired by the following Reedsy.com prompt: “Start your story with someone vowing to take revenge.”
Will Willoughby s a Maine-based writer and editor who’s also been a pizza guy, a projectionist, and a synergistic middle manager. His short stories have appeared in a number of publications, including Epiphany, Pithead Chapel, and Pangyrus. He’s been nominated for Best of the Net and the Pushcart Prize. In 2025, he won the Maine Literary Award for Short Fiction and was included on the “Other Distinguished Stories” list in The Best American Short Stories. Connect with him on Bluesky or Instagram. Read some of his stories at www.willwilloughby.com.